Fantasy Question: Best Keeper Package?

Ask the Staff: Fantasy Questions
Question from: Junior

Question - I play in a 10-keeper league and I'd like to know your opinion about those 4 packages of players... Those packages must not surpass the 1430 fantasy/pts limit that our league implanted.

Pack 1
1. D. McNabb-164.5
2. C. Palmer-195.5
3. L. Tomlinson-323
4. F. Gore-164
5. W. Parker-173
6. R. Wayne-157.5
7. M. Colston-130
8. D. Stallworth-82
9. Mike Peterson (defense) (injured last year but the year before he was a top-5 defensive player and is actually cheap)-28
10. Odell Thurman (defense) (was a good player in 2005 before being suspended last year.. he doesn't cost a thing on my cap but he's pretty much there to patch my 10th keeper and give him a shot next year)-0
TOTAL CAP: 1418.5

Pack 2
1. D. McNabb-164.5
2. C. Palmer-195.5
3. L. Tomlinson-323
4. F. Gore-164
5. W. Parker-173
6. R. Wayne-157.5
7. M. Colston-130
8. Ma. Clayton-110.5
9. O. Thurman-0
10. No one - Lost keeper
TOTAL CAP: 1418

Pack 3
1. D. McNabb-164.5
2. C. Palmer-195.5
3. L. Tomlinson-323
4. F. Gore-164
5. C. Benson-67
6. R. Wayne-157.5
7. M. Colston-130
8. Ma. Clayton-110.5
9. Vernon Davis-35.5
10. Chris Chambers-81.5
TOTAL CAP: 1429

Pack 4
1. D. McNabb-164.5
2. C. Palmer-195.5
3. L. Tomlinson-323
4. F. Gore-164
5. C. Benson-67
6. R. Wayne-157.5
7. M. Colston-130
8. Ma. Clayton-110.5
9. Vernon Davis-35.5
10. Donté Stallworth-82
+ a 2nd rounder
TOTAL CAP: 1429.5

In other words,

1 -Do you prefer Mark Clayton over Donté Stallworth? And if so, would you sacrifice a Mike Peterson (and a keeper spot at the same time) for him?

2 -Would you pull the trigger on a trade that would let go Willie Parker for Cendric Benson, Vernon Davis and Chris Chambers and at the same time would use all but one point of my cap space?

or

3 -Pull the trigger on a trade that send Parker and gives me Benson, Davis and a 2nd rounder (instead of Chambers) and replace him with Stallworth?

Thanks again in advance!

Click here for the reply.