Fantasy Question: Choosing Three Keepers

Ask the Staff: Fantasy Questions
Question from: Rick - I need to choose THREE keepers out of this bunch, and I'm not really sure who to keep. Here are the players, followed by the league settings.

Garret Anderson
Casey Blake
Joe Crede
J.D Drew
Prince Fielder
Juan Pierre
Edgar Renteria
Alex Rios
Jeremy Bonderman
Francisico Codero
Livan Hernandez
Chris Young
Pedro Martinez
Joe Nathan
Nate Roberston
Brad Penny

I need to pick THREE out of that bunch. Here are the league settings.

Scoring Type: Rotisserie
Player Universe: All of Baseball (NL and AL)
Positions:
1 Each: Catcher, 1st, 2nd, 3rd, SS, LF, CF, RF
1OF, 1IF, 1UTIL (UTIL is Newly Added: "The Hafner Slot")
Pitchers: Starting Pitchers, 3 (closers)
Bench: 9 Bench Slots
Injury Reserve: 3 IR Slots
Stat Categories:
Batters: Runs, Hits, Homeruns, RBI's, Stolen Bases, Batting Average,
Pitching: Wins, Shutouts, Saves, Strikeouts, ERA

Click here for the reply.