Addai/Jenkins vs Williams/Deion?

Fantasy Trade Questions: Ask the Staff

Question from: Tim

Question - Hi, I am in a keeper league, and battling for the lead. I am considering trading Joseph Addai and Michael Jenkins for Carnell Williams and Deion Branch. I feel like Addai has a bigger upside than Williams for the future, and I am wondering if Williams will have a stronger second half of the year. I am worried that once I make the trade, Addai will start getting much more playing time. That’s why I added Branch and Jenkins in on the deal. The other issue is that the my team salary will go up, but I still have a fair amount of cap room left. I guess the main thing I am thinking about is comparing Addai to Cadillac Williams, and would be very interested to hear your thoughts.

Thanks so much! Tim.

Click here for the reply.